The problem
Repeatedly multiply by 2 and keep only the remainder after division by 5. The remainders are 2, 4, 3, 1, then the cycle repeats: every nonzero remainder appears. Division by 7 gives 2, 4, 1, then repeats, missing 3, 5 and 6. Artin's conjecture asks whether one fixed eligible integer succeeds like the first example for a predicted positive share of primes. The integer can be any integer other than −1 or a perfect square, and primes dividing it are excluded.[1]
Fix an integer and multiply its successive powers modulo changing primes: how often does that one integer generate every nonzero remainder? Artin's conjecture predicts both a positive limiting proportion and its value. The fixed integer must be neither −1 nor a perfect square; primes dividing it are excluded.
For and , the powers give remainders 2, 4, 3 and 1. For , they give 2, 4 and 1. The multiplicative order is the first positive exponent returning the remainder 1; here it is 4 and 3 respectively. A primitive root has order , the number of nonzero remainders.
To define density, count successful primes up to a cutoff x and divide by , the number of all primes up to x. The conjecture predicts the limit of this fraction as x grows. The constant is not automatically the same for every eligible integer: algebraic dependencies can change the predicted proportion.[1]
Scope
For an integer a other than −1 or a perfect square, predict the density of primes p for which a is a primitive root modulo p.
What remains open
The predicted frequency has not been proved without extra assumptions.[1]
The density formula is known under a generalized Riemann hypothesis. The August 2026 paper instead assumes a non-abelian sieve inequality to prove infinitely many successful primes; its stated theorem is for 2, with extension to eligible integers discussed separately. Infinitely many successes is weaker than the full limiting-density formula. Neither establishes this page's unconditional target.[1] [2]
Why it matters
For the fixed integer 10, the same question governs how often reciprocals of primes have the longest possible repeating decimal. For example, one seventh repeats 142857, a six-digit block. It connects a familiar decimal pattern with the distribution of primes.[2]
Long division makes the connection to decimal expansions precise. For a prime p other than 2 or 5, the period of is the multiplicative order of 10 modulo p. If 10 is a primitive root, the period is the maximum . Thus the conjecture for 10 would predict how often this maximal decimal pattern occurs. More generally, it connects finite multiplication cycles to the arithmetic of number fields used to predict which primes exhibit them.[1] [2]
Definitions
4 terms
modulo
Working modulo a positive integer means keeping remainders after division by it. For example, .[1]
primitive root
For a prime p, a nonzero remainder whose successive powers visit all nonzero remainders before repeating.[1]
multiplicative order
For an integer a not divisible by a prime p, the least positive k with . It is the length of the power cycle.[1]
density
Here, the limiting fraction of all primes that satisfy a specified property, counted up to larger and larger cutoffs. This is a proportion among primes, not among all integers.[1]
Sources
- Refinements of Artin’s primitive root conjecture
Notes on Refinements of Artin’s primitive root conjecture
States the predicted positive density, its dependence on the fixed integer, and the generalized-Riemann-hypothesis condition.
- A non-abelian large sieve and Artin’s primitive root conjecture
Notes on A non-abelian large sieve and Artin’s primitive root conjecture
Assumes a non-abelian sieve inequality for infinitude, a weaker target than the full density formula; also explains decimal periods.