The problem
Small planets near their stars cluster into two size groups with a relative shortage in between. Did gas loss separate initially similar planets, or did they form with different rock and water inventories? High-energy starlight can power atmospheric escape, called photoevaporation; a cooling planet can also supply energy for core-powered loss. Mixed rocky and water-rich progenitors offer another explanation. The question is how much each contributes, rather than whether either mechanism can make a gap in a model.[1] [2]
Scope
The physical origin of the observed radius valley among close-in super-Earths and mini-Neptunes, including atmospheric loss and underlying composition populations.
What remains open
The March 2026 stellar-population analysis favors core-powered loss in its selected Kepler sample, but age groups mix different stellar populations. February simulations link a peak in orbital eccentricity to mixed progenitors under idealized mass and architecture assumptions; unseen companions also affect orbital interpretation. These are different tests, not a unique causal mixture established for all systems.[1] [2]
Why it matters
Definitions
3 terms
photoevaporation
Atmospheric escape powered by radiation from the star, especially high-energy light. It is one proposed way of shaping the radius valley.[1]
core-powered loss
Atmospheric escape supplied with energy as a planet’s interior cools. Evidence favoring it in one selected population does not establish its share in every system.[1]
eccentricity
How far an orbit departs from a circle; zero describes a circular orbit. Its interpretation also depends on a planet’s companions and dynamical history.[2]
Sources
- Insights into the Exoplanet Radius Valley from Host-Star Ages, Activity, Chemistry, and Birth Radius
Notes on Insights into the Exoplanet Radius Valley from Host-Star Ages, Activity, Chemistry, and Birth Radius
Accepted ApJ manuscript reports population trends favoring core-powered loss over a purely irradiation-driven account.
- Elevated Eccentricities in the Radius Valley Hint at Water-Rich Mini-Neptunes
Notes on Elevated Eccentricities in the Radius Valley Hint at Water-Rich Mini-Neptunes
Accepted ApJ study uses simulations to distinguish rocky-only and mixed rocky/icy populations; interpretation remains conditional.