Mazur’s separable quotient problem

Still openEvidence checked

Subjects: Analysis and dynamics

Collections: Groups and operators

Reading depth

The problem

Think of a space with infinitely many independent directions. A quotient forgets a closed collection of directions by treating vectors that differ along them as the same. Can this always leave infinitely many directions, yet a space approximable from a countable list?[1] [2]

Scope

Infinite-dimensional norm-separable Banach quotients of every infinite-dimensional real or complex Banach space.

What remains open

The answer is easy when the original space already has a countable dense list: forget nothing. The difficult case is an arbitrary nonseparable Banach space. Finding a smaller separable space inside it does not provide the required quotient.[1] [2]

Why it matters

Countable approximation lets retained vectors be studied through sequences. The problem is equivalent to asking for a quotient with a Schauder basis, where each vector has a convergent expansion in one sequence of basis vectors. This would bring that sequential description to an infinite-dimensional linear image even when the original space has no countable dense list.[1] [2]

Research directions

1 direction to explore

Definitions

3 terms
quotient

Identify vectors whose difference lies in a chosen closed linear subspace. The quotient norm is the infimum of distances to that subspace; closedness makes the quotient a complete normed space.[2]

norm-separable

There is a countable set of vectors approximating every vector arbitrarily closely in the norm. Density only for a weaker topology would not meet this requirement.[2]

Schauder basis

One sequence of vectors such that every vector has a unique expansion as a series in that sequence converging in norm. The equivalent question asks for such a basis on some infinite-dimensional quotient, not on the original space.[2]

Sources

Partial results
Kartik Patri

A nonseparable Bourgain-Pisier class has c₀ quotients. Scope: The general criterion and Lopez-Abad construction class stated in Theorem 1/Corollary 2.

The class restriction persists; the coordinate counterexample is not a counterexample to Mazur.

Source date: 2026-04-11Existence is proved without imposing the separate constructive coordinate assumption.Read the source ↗
  1. Mazur’s Separable Quotient Problem for Nonseparable Bourgain-Pisier ℒ∞-Spaces Kartik Patri · 2026-04-11
    Notes on Mazur’s Separable Quotient Problem for Nonseparable Bourgain-Pisier ℒ∞-Spaces

    Retains the universal Banach-space question while crediting a class-specific theorem and its narrower constructive assumption.

  2. On the separable quotient problem for Banach spaces J. C. Ferrando, J. Kąkol, M. López-Pellicer and W. Śliwa · 2017-09-27
    Notes on On the separable quotient problem for Banach spaces

    Explains quotient formulations and proved dual-space cases; separable subspaces do not settle existence of separable quotients.

Suggest a correction